15 Of The Hardest "Would You Rather" Questions For People Who Love "American Horror Story"

Love 'American Horror Story'? 🕯️🔪 Take this dark and twisted Would You Rather quiz to see how you’d survive the terrifying universe of AHS! 🖤👁️

This image was created with the assistance of DALL·E

Welcome to the dark, disturbing, and delightfully twisted world of American Horror Story, where no season is safe, no character truly survives, and every choice comes with a price. Whether you're obsessed with the ghosts of Murder House, the witches of Coven, or the horrors of Asylum, one thing is clear: you can never escape the madness—only choose how you live in it.

Which Terrifying Horror Doll Matches Your Vibe?

Would you rather join the witches of Miss Robichaux's Academy, or try to escape the walls of Briarcliff Manor? Could you survive the Hotel Cortez or face the cult-like chaos of AHS: Cult?

It’s time to test your instincts, your fears, and your darkest desires. Choose carefully—because in this world, every “Would You Rather” could be your last. 🖤🔪🕯️

Would you rather…?

Live in the Murder House, knowing the spirits will never let you leave 🏚️👻Be trapped in the Hotel Cortez, room key and all 🔑🩸

Would you rather…?

Be a witch under Fiona Goode’s rule in Coven 🕯️🖤Be a patient in Briarcliff, unsure if you’re sane or not 🧠🚪

Would you rather…?

Be forced to perform in Freak Show with a terrifying act 🎪🎭Be part of Cult, not knowing who to trust—or if you’re next 🐝🔪

Would you rather…?

Get possessed by a demon in Asylum 😈🧠Be experimented on by Dr. Arden 👨‍⚕️🧬

Would you rather…?

Have Madison Montgomery’s power of telekinesis 🧠💥Have Misty Day’s power to bring the dead back to life 🐦🌿

Would you rather…?

Face Twisty the Clown alone in a dark carnival tent 🤡🔦Be trapped in a house with the Rubber Man for a week 🏠🩸