"Stranger Things" Edition: 14 Would You Rather Scenarios That’ll Upset Everyone

Only true "Stranger Things" fans can survive these 14 gut-wrenching Would You Rather questions 😱 From Vecna to the Upside Down, prepare to choose — and cry

This image was created with the assistance of DALL·E

Think you're ready to survive Hawkins? Not without making some truly soul-crushing choices. In the world of Stranger Things, friendship is everything, trust is rare, and no one — not even your favorite character — is ever truly safe.

➡️ Which Would You Rather Date — A "Stranger Things" Character or the Person Behind the Role?

In this “Would You Rather” quiz, you’ll be asked to pick between some of the most impossible situations inspired by the show’s most painful, powerful, and paranormal moments. Will you close the gate or save your best friend? Choose the love triangle or the literal apocalypse? Trade safety for sacrifice or loyalty for survival?

➡️ 15 Of The Hardest "Would You Rather" Questions For People Who Love "Stranger Things"

These 14 questions are designed to pull at your nostalgic heartstrings, challenge your moral compass, and probably leave you sobbing somewhere near Castle Byers. Get ready — you’re not in the Upside Down yet, but emotionally? You're going there. 💀🔦🧃

Would you rather…?

Sacrifice Eleven to save Hawkins 🧠💥Risk everyone’s lives to keep her safe 🧍‍♀️🛡️

Would you rather…?

Let Max die to stop Vecna 💔🩸Save Max but keep the door to the Upside Down open forever 🕳️🌍

Would you rather…?

Watch Steve get taken by a Demogorgon 😢🧦Watch Eddie die… again 🎸🕳️

Would you rather…?

Live in the Upside Down for a year to protect your friends 🔦👁️Let someone else suffer in your place and live with the guilt 💭😔

Would you rather…?

Forget Will’s connection to the Mind Flayer and move on 🧠🕸️Dig back into the trauma and risk triggering everything again 🧃📼

Would you rather…?

Have Hopper die a hero and never come back 💀🇷🇺Bring him back but lose another major character instead 🎭🔁