Would You Rather: Naughty or Nice Scenarios Quiz!

Let’s dive into the ultimate holiday dilemma and find out if you’re on Santa’s naughty list or his nice list this year!

Would You Rather: Naughty or Nice Scenarios Quiz!

This image was created with the assistance of DALL·E 

Welcome to "Would You Rather: Naughty or Nice Scenarios!" Christmas is the time when we reflect on our behavior, and every year, we’re asked, "Have you been naughty or nice?" But which side of the holiday spectrum do you really fall on? This quiz will present you with a series of fun and festive dilemmas, where you’ll have to choose between the naughty side of the holidays or the sweet, kindhearted “nice” route.

Would you rather be the one sneaking cookies before Christmas morning or be the angel who volunteers at every charity event? Your answers will reveal whether you lean more toward mischievous holiday fun or embrace the holiday spirit of kindness and generosity!

So, let’s dive into the ultimate holiday dilemma and find out if you’re on Santa’s naughty list or his nice list this year!

Would you rather...
Sneak extra cookies from the plate meant for SantaOr bake and decorate a whole batch of cookies to leave for Santa
Would you rather...
Shake the presents under the tree to guess what’s insideOr wait patiently and excitedly for Christmas morning to open them
Would you rather...
Tell everyone you’re on Santa’s “naughty” list just to get attentionOr donate some of your gifts to those in need
Would you rather...
Stay up all night to try and catch a glimpse of SantaOr go to bed early, leaving out cookies and milk for Santa in the hopes of a surprise
Would you rather...
Get caught sneaking a peek at your presents before ChristmasOr wait until Christmas morning to enjoy your surprises
Would you rather...
Borrow a Christmas decoration without askingOr spend the whole season helping others decorate their homes
Would you rather...
Play pranks on your family and friends during the holiday seasonOr organize a thoughtful holiday charity event to give back to the community
Would you rather...
Open your presents in secret before the big dayOr watch others open their gifts, enjoying their reactions
Would you rather...
Ignore your holiday responsibilities to enjoy some extra sleepOr volunteer your time to make the holidays brighter for others
Would you rather...
Steal a piece of candy from the Christmas candy bowlOr share all your favorite treats with your family and friends
Would you rather...
Secretly peek at your holiday cards before they’re openedOr take the time to write heartfelt messages in each card you give

More Like This
Are You Naughty, Nice, or Somewhere in Between?
Are You Naughty, Nice, or Somewhere in Between? quiz
What Christmas Gift Are You Destined to Give?
What Christmas Gift Are You Destined to Give? quiz
Which American Christmas Movie Character Are You?
Which American Christmas Movie Character Are You? quiz
Would You Rather: Magical Christmas Villages or Bustling Holiday Cities?
Would You Rather: Magical Christmas Villages or Bustling Holiday Cities? quiz
Would You Rather: Spend Christmas in the North Pole or on a Tropical Island?
Would You Rather: Spend Christmas in the North Pole or on a Tropical Island? quiz
Would You Rather: Christmas Traditions Edition!
Would You Rather: Christmas Traditions Edition! quiz
What Kind of Christmas Magic Powers Do You Have?
What Kind of Christmas Magic Powers Do You Have? quiz
Is Your Christmas Spirit a Sparkle or a Blaze?
Is Your Christmas Spirit a Sparkle or a Blaze? quiz
Can You Name These Classic Christmas Carols?
Can You Name These Classic Christmas Carols? word quest
Latest
What Christmas Drink Matches Your Holiday Vibe?
What Christmas Drink Matches Your Holiday Vibe? quiz
Would You Rather: Santa's Workshop Dilemmas
Would You Rather: Santa's Workshop Dilemmas quiz
Would You Rather: Naughty or Nice Scenarios Quiz!
Would You Rather: Naughty or Nice Scenarios Quiz! quiz
Music Genres Word Quest: Can You Name These Popular Styles?
Music Genres Word Quest: Can You Name These Popular Styles? word quest
What Christmas Treat Are You?
What Christmas Treat Are You? quiz
Which Traditional Christmas Ornament Are You?
Which Traditional Christmas Ornament Are You? quiz
Sports Events Word Quest: How Well Do You Know These Classic Competitions?
Sports Events Word Quest: How Well Do You Know These Classic Competitions? word quest
What's Your Christmas Personality?
What's Your Christmas Personality? quiz
Would You Rather: Holiday Food Face-Off
Would You Rather: Holiday Food Face-Off quiz
See all