Would You Rather: Spend a Night at MacLaren’s or at Puzzles, the Fake Bar?

Would you rather spend a legendary night at MacLaren’s or risk total chaos at Puzzles? 🍻🔥 Take this How I Met Your Mother Would You Rather quiz and find out where you belong! 🎤🎭

When it comes to grabbing a drink with your best friends, two bars stand out in How I Met Your Mother history—MacLaren’s, the gang’s iconic hangout spot, and Puzzles, Barney and Ted’s ridiculous, rule-breaking, anything-goes bar experiment.

Legendary 'How I Met Your Mother' Challenge: How Much Do You Know about Marshall, Lily, Ted, Barney, and Robin?

At MacLaren’s, you’d enjoy a classic New York pub experience, where you can chill in the booth with your closest friends, sip on your favorite drink, and listen to Marshall tell a weird story that somehow lasts an hour.

Marshall, Barney, or Ted: Which "How I Met Your Mother" Character Is the Perfect Boyfriend for You?

At Puzzles, however, there are no rules, no cover charge, and no guarantees that things won’t get totally out of control. You might find yourself singing in a full-blown musical number, helping Barney with a ridiculous scheme, or being part of the most epic night you’ll never remember.

Do You Know "How I Met Your Mother" Well?

So, would you rather have a chill night at MacLaren’s, or risk total chaos at Puzzles? Grab a drink, and let’s find out! 🍻🔥🎤

Would you rather…?
Kick back in the iconic MacLaren’s booth with the gang 🍻🛋️Experience the unpredictable madness of Puzzles for one insane night 🔥🎤
Would you rather…?
Have your usual drink served to you without question at MacLaren’s 🍺🍹Have a mystery drink that may or may not be flammable at Puzzles 🔥🥃
Would you rather…?
Listen to one of Marshall’s ridiculously long but hilarious stories 🗣️😂Watch Barney perform an over-the-top magic trick that defies logic 🎩✨
Would you rather…?
Have Wendy the Waitress bring you free drinks all night 🍷💃Have Barney bribe you to be his "wingman" for the night 😏🔥
Would you rather…?
Sing along to Robin Sparkles’ "Let’s Go to the Mall" at MacLaren’s karaoke night 🎤🎶Be part of an out-of-nowhere musical number at Puzzles 🎭🎹
Would you rather…?
Sit at the bar and listen to Ted explain architecture for way too long 🏛️😅Get dragged into one of Barney’s outrageous and probably illegal schemes 🎩🚨
Would you rather…?
Play a legendary round of "Have You Met Ted?" at MacLaren’s 💕🍻Try out a fake identity for a night at Puzzles just for fun 🕶️🎭
Would you rather…?
Enjoy a drama-free, chill evening at MacLaren’s with your best friends 🛋️📖Have a wild night at Puzzles where you wake up with no memory of what happened 😵🔥
Would you rather…?
Laugh at Barney’s ridiculous pick-up lines in a normal bar setting 😂💋Watch Barney actually succeed in convincing someone that "Puzzles" is a real bar 🤣🥂
Would you rather…?
Hear Lily and Marshall’s adorable couple banter over drinks at MacLaren’s 💕🍷Watch Ted drunkenly declare his love to someone at Puzzles 😬💘
Would you rather…?
Order the Eriksen family’s secret Minnesota drink, "Tantrum," at MacLaren’s 🟢🍹Try whatever bizarre, unnamed drink Barney is serving at Puzzles 🔥🥃
Would you rather…?
Be a regular at MacLaren’s and always have a reserved booth 🍻🛋️Be part of the one and only night Puzzles ever opens 🎉🥂
Would you rather…?
Win a drinking contest against Barney at MacLaren’s 🍺🏆Beat Marshall in a slap bet at Puzzles 👋😂
Would you rather…?
Enjoy a legendary night that you actually remember at MacLaren’s 📸🍻Have the most epic night of your life at Puzzles, but forget everything 🤯🔥

💛☂️

More "How I Met Your Mother" quizzes >>>

More Like This
Which "How I Met Your Mother" Character Would Be Your Roommate?
Which "How I Met Your Mother" Character Would Be Your Roommate? quiz
How I Met Your Mother Word Quest: Name These Legendary Characters!
How I Met Your Mother Word Quest: Name These Legendary Characters! word quest
Which How I Met Your Mother Character Are You?
Which How I Met Your Mother Character Are You? quiz
Do You Know "How I Met Your Mother" Well?
Do You Know "How I Met Your Mother" Well? trivia quiz
How I Met Your Mother Quiz: Are You More Ted, Marshall, or Barney?
How I Met Your Mother Quiz: Are You More Ted, Marshall, or Barney? quiz
How I Met Your Mother Quiz: Are You More Lily or Robin?
How I Met Your Mother Quiz: Are You More Lily or Robin? quiz
Latest
Which 2025 Hit Song Describes Your Year?
Which 2025 Hit Song Describes Your Year? quiz
Your Celebrity Twin: Who Do You Match With?
Your Celebrity Twin: Who Do You Match With? quiz
Christmas Dinner Foods First and Last Letter Challenge
Christmas Dinner Foods First and Last Letter Challenge word quest
How Christmas Almost Got Banned (Multiple Times in History)
How Christmas Almost Got Banned (Multiple Times in History) article
Bookworms Beware: 16 Cruel Would You Rather Questions You’ll Hate to Answer
Bookworms Beware: 16 Cruel Would You Rather Questions You’ll Hate to Answer quiz
Only Real Fans Can Score 100% on This 'Resident Evil' Trivia Quiz
Only Real Fans Can Score 100% on This 'Resident Evil' Trivia Quiz trivia quiz
How Rare Is Your Personality? Find Out Now
How Rare Is Your Personality? Find Out Now quiz
What's Your 2025 Vibe Check? Aesthetic Personality Quiz
What's Your 2025 Vibe Check? Aesthetic Personality Quiz quiz
Holiday Gift Personality Quiz: What Do You Really Want?
Holiday Gift Personality Quiz: What Do You Really Want? quiz
See all