A True Potterhead’s Nightmare: 17 Would You Rather Questions From the Wizarding World

Only true Potterheads can survive these 17 gut-wrenching “Would You Rather” questions 🧙‍♂️ Choose between heartbreaking wizarding world dilemmas — if you dare

Think you're the ultimate wizarding world expert? Let’s put your loyalty, bravery, wit, and ambition to the test — because this quiz doesn’t pull any punches. From choosing between Hogwarts houses to picking who survives a duel, these 17 "Would You Rather" scenarios are designed to shake even the most confident Potterheads to their magical cores.

🪄 Try This Epic Word Quest: Harry Potter Magical Objects First and Last Letter Challenge

Whether you’re standing in the Great Hall or wandering the Forbidden Forest, these dilemmas dive deep into the stories, relationships, and legacies of Harry Potter. Would you save Fred Weasley or Dobby? Join the Death Eaters to protect your family? Destroy a Horcrux at a cost no one should pay?

🪄 The Ultimate Harry Potter Fan Quiz: 20 Brutal Would You Rather Choices

Some questions will test your heart. Others will challenge your head. But one thing’s for sure — no spell or Time-Turner can undo what you choose here.

🪄 Would You Rather: Be a Wizard in 'Harry Potter' or a Jedi in 'Star Wars'?

Grab your wand. It's time to face the most impossible magical choices ever imagined. ⚡🕯️🦉

Would you rather…?

Save Fred Weasley but lose Lupin and Tonks 💔🧡Save Lupin and Tonks but let Fred die in the Battle of Hogwarts 🕊️💀

Would you rather…?

Have a seat at the Slytherin table for a year 🐍📚Be forced to wear a “Muggle-born” label in a hostile Hogwarts 🧍‍♂️🚫

Would you rather…?

Use the Elder Wand to defeat Voldemort — but keep it afterward 💀🪄Destroy the wand immediately and fight without it ⚔️⚰️

Would you rather…?

Obliviate Hermione and she forgets you forever 💭🪄Let her suffer emotional pain she may never recover from 😔📚

Would you rather…?

Watch Dobby die again 😢🧦Let Hedwig take the curse in his place 🦉💥