Pick a Terrible Fate for a Traitor Witch and Find Your True Dark Side

You must sentence a traitor witch for breaking the sacred pact. What you choose reveals the part of you that punishes in secret - and why

This image was created with the assistance of Freepik

The coven gathers under a blood moon. You stand in the center, cloak heavy with ash and night. Before you, a traitor kneels—bound by spell-silken rope, eyes closed.

She broke the pact. Whispered sacred things to those who never earned them. Magic is a trust, and she fractured it with a smile.

No one else will act. This choice, this judgment, falls to you.

The circle hums, waiting. The fire crackles, expectant. The air tastes like iron.

What terrible fate do you choose for the traitor witch?

🔥 Option 1: Banish her soul to wander forgotten places—forever nameless

🪞 Option 2: Trap her in a mirror, where she must face herself for eternity

🌊 Option 3: Drown her in a moonlit lake—her magic dissolving with her

🪦 Option 4: Bury her beneath the roots of the oldest tree, unheard, unmourned

🕊️ Option 5: Forgive her—but mark her, so all may know what she did

What Your Choice Reveals About Your True Dark Side

🔥 The Exiler — You fear insignificance

You cast her out, unseen and unnamed. This reveals a deep fear within you: to be forgotten, erased, made meaningless. You punish by stripping identity because your shadow self equates worth with memory. You’re powerful, but only when you’re remembered. Your dark side? You haunt to prove you mattered.

🪞 The Reflector — You fear what lives inside

Forcing her to face herself forever reveals your obsession with inner truth—and your terror of it. You punish by forcing introspection because your shadow self fears what would happen if others saw your real reflection. Your dark side? You weaponize mirrors because you can’t shatter your own.

🌊 The Eraser — You fear loss of control

Drowning her, dissolving her magic—this reveals your desire to cleanse what cannot be controlled. Your punishment is final, clean, irreversible. You fear the chaotic, the unpredictable, the emotional. Your dark side? You destroy what reminds you of your own volatility.

🪦 The Burier — You fear being buried alive in silence

Your justice is quiet. Cold. Covered in earth and forgotten history. You punish with silence because your own wounds were met with none. Your shadow self longs to be heard—but has learned to bury pain instead. Your dark side? You bury others to avoid digging up yourself.

🕊️ The Mark-Bearer — You fear becoming the villain

You forgive—but make sure no one forgets. This reveals a hunger for moral high ground. You need to be seen as fair, as good, even when you punish. Your shadow self fears its own cruelty, so it dresses vengeance as virtue. Your dark side? You punish with purity—so you don’t have to admit you enjoyed it.

So—what fate did you give the witch? Your judgment wasn’t about justice. It was about the part of you that fears becoming what you punish.

🕯️ Now it’s your turn: Share this ritual with someone who walks the darker woods. What fate would they choose—and what would it reveal?