The problem with ebook filesharing is simply one of scale. But I think the "piracy" problem is massively over-rated.
Charles StrossPeople want to buy mp3s but can't? Piracy ensues. Then Apple strong-arms the music studios into the iTunes store and music piracy drops somewhat. The same, I believe, is also happening with ebooks.
Charles StrossOne ape's hallucination is another ape's religious experience - it just depends on which oneโs god module is overactive at the time.
Charles StrossAny replacement to the current copyright position (life plus 70 years) needs to have an answer lined up for this, and similar, messy edge cases.
Charles Stross