Preaching Christianity to skeptics without first setting out the praeambula fidei [preambles of faith], and then complaining when they donโt accept it, is like yelling in English at someone who only speaks Chinese, and then dismissing him as a fool when he doesnโt understand you. In both cases, while there is certainly a fool in the picture, it isnโt the listener.
Edward FeserDawkinsโs problem is that he doesnโt know the difference between probabilistic empirical theorizing and strict metaphysical demonstration, and thus misreads an attempt at the latter as if it were the former. That is not to say that Aquinas might not be mistaken at some point in the argument โ though obviously I donโt think he is โ but if youโre going to show that he is, you first need to understand what kind of argument he is giving, and thus what kind of mistake heโd be making if heโs made one at all.
Edward FeserAtheists tend to read only each otherโs books and not the work of the religious thinkers they are supposedly refuting.
Edward Feser