I believe that a core problem with undergraduate education, especially at research universities like Harvard, Stanford, NYU, etc, is that most teaching is done by PhDs, who by temperament, training, interests, and rewards are researchers first. So they spend most of their time and energy probing a snip of a field's cutting edge. In my view, the attributes needed to be a transformative undergraduate instructor are pretty orthogonal to that. It would seem that undergraduate education would be superior if there was a separate track for teaching faculty.
Marty NemkoI believe the personal essay is underrated for both writer and reader. It affords the writer great freedom: to speak personally yet invoke others' ideas, to be rational and/or emotional, to be confident or admit doubt.
Marty NemkoAnswering ads rarely works for career changers because you have no experience in the job for which you're applying.
Marty NemkoSome parents let kids "learn on their own skin" and many of those kids end up, as adults, languishing on their parents' sofas.
Marty NemkoEducation isn't a magic pill. There is no magic pill. But the closest we have is practical expertise and relentless drive.
Marty NemkoBeing a good writer may result in your being nicer to more people, having a bigger positive impact.
Marty NemkoYou might want to keep trying to rise, using a path that builds on your natural strengths: sales, analysis, managing people, whatever, and keep asking for honest feedback. When you reach the point at which it feels clear you've topped out, revise your job description or take a step back. Up is not the only way.
Marty Nemko