In these unfiltered, un-moderated social media posts people are speculating about others' motivations. And you could no more put that in a peer review for a journal than you could fly.
Susan FiskePromoting open and critical and respectful scientific discourse seems like a pretty good goal to me.
Susan FiskeIf people are going to do post-publication peer review, they need to abide by the same rules as they abide by for pre-publication peer review: not being ad hominem, being respectful, giving the author a chance to respond in a reasonable way.
Susan Fiske